Key takeaways
- Power the drive off at the first sign of physical failure, because running it longer can turn a recoverable fault into a permanent one.
- Never run CHKDSK, format the drive, or install recovery software onto a drive you need data from.
- Deleted files on an SSD are often unrecoverable because of TRIM, so stop using the computer straight away.
- If a NAS or RAID array is degraded, don't start a rebuild until you know your data is backed up and the remaining drives are healthy.
- Check OneDrive, iCloud, Google Photos and any backup drive before paying for recovery.
A failing drive often gives you one good chance at recovery. What you do in the first hour, and mostly what you don't do, decides whether the files come back cheaply, expensively or not at all. Here's how to recognise a dying drive, what to avoid, and what professional recovery involves.
Signs your hard drive or SSD is failing
- Clicking, grinding or beeping from a hard drive. A rhythmic click is the classic sign of failed read/write heads.
- Not detected. The drive doesn't appear in File Explorer, Disk Management or the BIOS, or a Mac says the disk isn't readable.
- Very slow or freezing. Opening a folder hangs for minutes, file copies stall partway, or the computer freezes whenever it touches certain files.
- SMART warnings. The drive's self-monitoring reports reallocated or pending sectors, or Windows warns that it has detected a hard disk problem.
- Wrong name or capacity. An SSD that shows up with an odd model name or a tiny capacity usually has a failed controller.
- "You need to format the disk". Windows offering to format a drive full of data means the file system is damaged, not that the data is gone.
The first thing to do: stop
Shut the computer down, or unplug the external drive, and leave it off. If the drive has a physical fault, every minute it runs can make things worse. Damaged heads can scrape the platter surface, and a drive with weak sectors can degrade further each time it's read.
If the computer still works and the problem is deleted files, stop using it too. Anything new written to the drive, including browser cache and updates, can overwrite the files you want back.
Then check whether you need recovery at all. Photos may already be in iCloud or Google Photos, work files in OneDrive or SharePoint, and email on the mail server. Ten minutes of checking can save the cost of a recovery.
What not to do before data recovery
- Don't freeze it. The freezer trick doesn't help modern drives, and condensation on the platters can cause a head crash.
- Don't open it. Hard drives are assembled in cleanrooms because a single dust particle can damage heads that fly a tiny distance above the platter. Opening one outside a cleanroom makes recovery harder and dearer.
- Don't keep rebooting. Each power cycle on a clicking or failing drive is another chance for the heads to damage the platters.
- Don't run CHKDSK or Disk Utility's First Aid. These tools repair the file system by rewriting it, which can permanently discard the records needed to rebuild your folders. They also read the whole disk, which stresses a weak drive.
- Don't format or initialise. Click Cancel when Windows offers to format the disk.
- Don't install recovery software onto the same drive. Installing writes data, possibly straight over the files you want back.
- Don't swap the circuit board. Modern drives store drive-specific calibration data on the board, so a board from an identical model usually won't work and can cause further damage.
- Don't tap, shake or knock it to try to get it spinning.
- Don't dry out water damage with heat. Leave a wet drive or laptop powered off and bring it in as it is.
Deleted files on an SSD: the TRIM problem
On a traditional hard drive, deleting a file only removes the reference to it, so the data stays put until something overwrites it. SSDs work differently. Modern operating systems use a command called TRIM to tell the SSD which blocks are no longer needed, and the drive clears them in the background to keep itself fast.
The result is that deleted files on a modern SSD often can't be recovered at all, and the odds drop the longer the computer stays on. Turn it off straight away. It's still worth sending an SSD to the lab, but go in with realistic expectations.
NAS and RAID: don't rebuild blindly
When one drive in a NAS fails, a Synology reports the storage pool as degraded. Your data is still there, but the redundancy has gone. The tempting move is to slot in a new drive and start a repair straight away. Before you do:
- Confirm you have a current backup of the NAS. If you don't, copy the most important data off first while the pool is still readable.
- Check the health of the remaining drives. Drives bought together tend to wear out together, and a rebuild reads every sector of every remaining drive.
- Replace only the failed drive, in its original bay.
If a second drive fails during a rebuild on a single-redundancy array, such as RAID 5 or SHR with one-drive fault tolerance, the pool can crash and take the data with it. If the pool already shows as crashed, stop. Don't reinitialise it, create a new pool or swap drives between bays. Label each drive with its bay number and send it to a lab.
Logical vs physical failure, and what recovery costs
A logical failure means the drive itself works, but the data is damaged or missing. A physical failure means the hardware has failed: heads, motor, circuit board, or an SSD's controller or memory. Either way, the drive goes to our partner lab, Fields Data Recovery, which works out which one you're dealing with and quotes before any work starts:
| Path | Typical cases | Price |
|---|---|---|
| Partner lab (Fields Data Recovery) | Deleted or formatted files, failing drives, clicking or not spinning drives, water and fire damage, failed SSD controllers, RAID arrays | A fixed quote from the lab before any work starts |
Start a case with the referral form on our data recovery page. We work with hard drives, SSD and NVMe drives, laptops and desktops, USB sticks and SD cards, external drives, and NAS and RAID arrays. Phones and tablets are assessed case by case. There's more detail on our data recovery page.
A simple checklist when a drive dies
- Power it off and leave it off.
- Write down what happened: noises, error messages, any drops or spills, and anything you've already tried.
- Check OneDrive, iCloud, Google Photos, email and any backup drive for copies.
- Find any encryption keys or passwords, including your BitLocker recovery key.
- List the folders that matter most, so recovery can prioritise them.
- Get a professional diagnostic before trying software or repairs yourself.
Once the files are back, set up backups so a dead drive is a minor inconvenience next time. Our guide to backing up photos and important files covers the home side, and businesses should look at cloud and backup services or a properly configured Synology NAS.