Insights · Security

Why Every Business Should Use Multi-Factor Authentication

Key takeaways

  • MFA means a stolen or guessed password alone can't open an account, which covers most everyday credential attacks.
  • Authenticator apps with number matching are far safer than SMS codes, and passkeys or security keys are stronger again.
  • Start with Microsoft 365 or Google email, admin accounts, banking, accounting software and remote access.
  • Block legacy sign-in methods and plan for lost phones, or MFA will either leave gaps or lock out your own staff.
  • MFA is included in Microsoft 365 at no extra cost, so the real cost is setup time and a short period of staff adjustment.

A password is one secret, and secrets leak. Staff reuse them across sites, criminals buy leaked lists and phishing pages ask for them directly. Multi-factor authentication (MFA) adds a second proof, so a stolen password alone can't open the account. It's the cheapest high-value security control a business can switch on.

Why do passwords alone fail?

Most attacks on businesses don't involve clever hacking. Someone gets a working username and password, and signs in like a normal user. The usual routes are:

  • Phishing: a fake Microsoft 365 or bank sign-in page collects credentials.
  • Reused passwords: a login leaked from an unrelated website is tried against your email. You can check an address at haveibeenpwned.com.
  • Password spraying: one common password is tried across many accounts.

Once inside a mailbox, an attacker can read invoices, set up forwarding rules and send convincing payment-redirect emails to your customers. The Australian Cyber Security Centre treats MFA as one of the Essential Eight baseline controls for this reason. More on that in our Essential Eight explainer.

Which MFA methods are strongest?

Not all second factors are equal. Here they are from weakest to strongest.

Method How it works Weakness
SMS code A text message with a six-digit code SIM swap fraud and phishing. Better than nothing.
Authenticator app code A rotating code in an app on your phone Can be typed into a fake site and captured.
App prompt with number matching Approve a sign-in by entering the number shown on screen Harder to approve by accident, though still phishable with a live fake page.
Passkey or FIDO2 security key Your device or key proves your identity directly to the real site Resistant to phishing. Needs a plan for lost devices.

For most businesses, the Microsoft Authenticator app with number matching is the practical default. Move administrators and anyone handling payments to passkeys or hardware keys when you can.

Passkeys are tied to a device and confirmed with a fingerprint, face or PIN. They can't be typed into a fake website, which is why they resist phishing. Windows Hello, iPhones, Android phones and Macs already support them, so many staff devices are ready.

Do businesses really need MFA?

Yes. Attackers don't pick businesses one by one. Automated tools test leaked passwords against thousands of Microsoft 365 sign-in pages, and the accounts without MFA are the ones that fall. Size doesn't protect you, because an unguarded mailbox is the target.

There are practical reasons too. Cyber insurance forms commonly ask whether MFA is enforced on email and remote access, and larger clients increasingly ask suppliers the same question. Setup is mostly an afternoon of configuration, and on a Microsoft 365 or Google Workspace plan you already pay for, it costs only staff time.

Where should MFA be turned on first?

Start where a breach hurts most, then work outward:

  1. Microsoft 365 or Google Workspace sign-in for every user, which covers email, files and Teams.
  2. All administrator accounts, including your domain registrar, DNS provider and firewall.
  3. Internet banking and payroll platforms.
  4. Accounting software such as Xero or MYOB.
  5. Remote access: VPN, remote desktop and remote support tools.
  6. Your password manager and any cloud backup console.
  7. Social media and advertising accounts, which are targeted for scams.

How do I turn on MFA in Microsoft 365?

There are two main ways, and the better one depends on your licence.

  • Security defaults. A free, all-or-nothing setting that requires MFA registration for all users, and for admins when they sign in. It's in the Microsoft Entra admin centre under Identity, Overview, Properties, Manage security defaults. It's a good starting point for very small teams.
  • Conditional access. Available with Microsoft 365 Business Premium. You write rules such as "require MFA for all users on all apps" or "block sign-ins from outside Australia". It gives more control than security defaults and lets you exempt specific cases safely. See our Microsoft 365 page for how we set it up.

The older per-user MFA setting, found under Active users in the Microsoft 365 admin centre, still works but is being replaced by these two approaches. Don't mix them without a plan.

Two details catch people out. First, block legacy authentication, the older email protocols that can't prompt for a second factor and so bypass MFA entirely. Second, create one or two emergency admin accounts, with long passwords stored offline, so a misconfigured rule can't lock everyone out. Microsoft documents both at support.microsoft.com.

How do I roll out MFA without annoying staff?

MFA succeeds or fails on rollout. A poorly handled switch-on produces lockouts, support calls and pressure to turn it off.

  1. Tell people first. Explain what's changing, why, and the date. Two sentences in an email beats a surprise prompt.
  2. Do a pilot. Switch it on for yourself and one or two staff and fix whatever breaks.
  3. Register two methods per person. An authenticator app plus a second option, so a lost phone isn't an emergency.
  4. Set sensible prompts. Trusted office devices can be asked less often through conditional access, while new devices and locations always get challenged.
  5. Handle the awkward cases. Shared mailboxes, scanners that email documents, and older apps may need different arrangements.
  6. Plan for replacements. Decide who removes and re-registers MFA when a phone is lost, and how they verify identity.

It usually takes a week or two for staff to stop noticing it. For businesses that don't want to manage this themselves, MFA and conditional access are enforced as part of our Pro managed IT plan, at $169 per user per month ex GST. Our cybersecurity work covers the rest of the Essential Eight alongside it.

A simple MFA checklist

  • Is MFA required for every Microsoft 365 or Google user, with no exceptions?
  • Do all admin and banking accounts have it, using the strongest method available?
  • Are legacy sign-in protocols blocked?
  • Does every person have a second registered method or backup codes?
  • Does someone know the process when a phone is lost or replaced?
  • Do staff know to deny prompts they didn't start?

If a staff member's account has already been compromised, see what to do if your email or online account has been hacked. To make the passwords side stronger too, read why password managers are worth using.

FAQ

Questions people ask

Does multi-factor authentication cost anything?

The basic version doesn't. Microsoft 365 includes security defaults and the Microsoft Authenticator app at no extra cost, and Google Workspace includes 2-Step Verification. More advanced controls, such as targeted conditional access rules, need a licence like Microsoft 365 Business Premium.

Is SMS MFA good enough?

It's better than a password alone, but it's the weakest common option. Criminals can hijack phone numbers through SIM swap fraud, and text codes can be phished. Use an authenticator app, passkey or security key wherever the service supports it.

What happens if an employee loses their phone?

An administrator removes the old MFA registration and the person re-registers on a new device. Good practice is to verify the person's identity first, usually by calling them on a known number. Staff can also register a second method in advance, such as a security key or backup code.

Can MFA be bypassed?

Yes, in some cases. Attackers use prompt bombing to wear people down, or phishing sites that capture the code in real time. Number matching, phishing-resistant methods such as passkeys, and staff who know to deny unexpected prompts close most of these gaps.

Do I need MFA if I use a password manager?

Yes, for both. A password manager makes passwords unique and strong, but MFA protects the account if one is still stolen. Put MFA on the password manager itself too, because it holds everything else.

Keep reading

More on security

Tell us what's going on. We'll tell you what it costs.

Free consultations for businesses. Fixed-price quotes before any work starts.

Private design preview