Insights · Backup & Data

Cloud Storage vs Backups: What's the Difference?

Key takeaways

  • Cloud storage mirrors your changes everywhere, including mistakes and ransomware, so it is not a backup on its own.
  • A real backup is separate from the original, keeps multiple restore points and can't be deleted by a normal user account.
  • Recycle bins and version history expire, commonly after 30 days on personal accounts, so late discoveries are often unrecoverable.
  • Follow the 3-2-1 rule and test a restore at least twice a year.

Cloud storage keeps your files available on every device. A backup keeps separate copies you can restore from when files are deleted, corrupted or encrypted by ransomware. They look similar, which is why so many people assume OneDrive, Google Drive or iCloud is their backup. For most of the problems that actually cost people data, it isn't.

What does cloud storage actually do?

Services such as OneDrive, Google Drive, Dropbox and iCloud Drive are built around sync. A folder on your computer mirrors a folder online, and a change in one place shows up in the other. Delete a file on your laptop and it disappears from your phone and the web. Overwrite a good spreadsheet with a bad one and the bad one is now everywhere.

That is exactly what you want for sharing and working across devices. It is also why sync fails as a safety net in these common situations:

  • Accidental deletion. The delete spreads to every synced device within moments.
  • Ransomware. Encrypted files sync up as the newest version. Version history can roll them back, but restoring thousands of files by hand is slow and easy to get wrong.
  • A hacked or locked account. If someone takes over your account, or the provider suspends it, the data goes with it.
  • Expired retention. Recycle bins and version history only hold changes for a limited time. OneDrive's recycle bin keeps deleted items for 30 days on personal accounts and 93 days on work or school accounts. Google Drive's trash keeps items for 30 days. Notice a problem after that and the file is gone.
  • Bad sync. A fault, a full disk or a half-finished sync can leave an empty or damaged folder that then replaces the good copy.

What makes something a real backup?

A backup is a deliberate, independent copy of your data that you can restore from. Four properties separate it from sync:

  1. It is separate. The copy sits on a different device, in a different account or at a different location from the original.
  2. It keeps history. You can go back to last night, last week or last month, not just the latest version.
  3. It is protected. A normal user account, or ransomware running as that user, can't delete or encrypt it. That usually means immutable storage, an offline copy or a separate set of credentials.
  4. It has been tested. Someone has restored real files from it and knows how long that takes.

Cloud storage, local backup and cloud backup compared

Situation Cloud storage (OneDrive, Google Drive, iCloud) Local backup (external drive or NAS) Cloud backup service
Main job Access and share files from anywhere Fast restore after a fault or deletion Offsite copy that survives a site disaster
Deleted file, noticed within days Recoverable from the recycle bin Recoverable from history or snapshots Recoverable from history
Deleted file, noticed months later Usually gone Recoverable if history is long enough Recoverable if retention is long enough
Ransomware Syncs the damage, rollback possible but manual Safe only if the drive isn't connected or the snapshots are protected Safe if the copy is immutable or kept under separate credentials
Hardware failure Files survive in the cloud Files survive on the second device Files survive
Fire, flood or theft Files survive Lost if the backup is in the same room Files survive
Restoring everything Slow, file by file Fast over the local network Limited by your internet speed

No single column covers everything. Local backups restore quickly but share a building with the original. Cloud backups survive a disaster but restore at internet speed. That's why the usual answer is two of them.

Is OneDrive enough for my business?

Microsoft keeps its service running and protects its infrastructure. Your data is your responsibility, and Microsoft's own service agreement recommends you back up your content regularly. A departing employee who deletes a SharePoint library, a compromised mailbox or a ransomware infection on one PC can all cause losses that fall outside the recycle bin window.

A Microsoft 365 backup copies mail, OneDrive and SharePoint to a separate location with its own retention. Our Pro and Elite managed IT plans include it. If you are working through which licences you need, the Business Basic vs Business Standard comparison is a good companion read.

What about family photos and phone files at home?

Home users get caught the same way. iCloud Photos and Google Photos mirror your library across devices, so deleting a photo on one phone removes it everywhere, and the Recently Deleted or bin folder only holds it for a limited time. If your only copy of a child's first year lives in a sync service, it has no backup.

A sensible home setup is an external drive or a small Synology NAS in the house, plus a cloud backup of photos and documents. Our post on backing up family photos and important files walks through it step by step.

How does the 3-2-1 rule apply?

The 3-2-1 rule is the standard test: keep three copies of your data, on two different types of storage, with one copy offsite. Your working files on the laptop are copy one. Cloud sync doesn't count as an independent copy, because it changes whenever the original changes. A local backup is copy two, and a cloud backup is copy three, offsite.

Many people now add a fourth idea: keep at least one copy offline or immutable, so ransomware can't reach it. The Australian Cyber Security Centre lists regular, tested backups as one of the Essential Eight. Our Essential Eight explainer covers the rest.

A simple checklist

  1. List the data you can't replace: photos, tax records, accounting files, customer data, project files.
  2. Find where each item lives today. If the answer is only a sync folder, it has no backup yet.
  3. Turn on version history in your cloud storage, and learn where the recycle bin is.
  4. Add an independent backup: an external drive or NAS with history, plus an offsite cloud copy.
  5. Protect the backup with a different login from your day-to-day account, and enable multi-factor authentication on it.
  6. Twice a year, delete a test file and restore it, then time a restore of a whole folder.

If a drive has already failed and you have no backup, stop using it and read what to do before data recovery. Our data recovery service is built for that situation.

FAQ

Questions people ask

Is OneDrive a backup?

Not on its own. OneDrive syncs a folder between your devices and the cloud, so a deletion or an encrypted file syncs too. It has a recycle bin and version history that help for a limited time, but a separate backup of your OneDrive data is the safer approach for a business.

Is Google Drive or iCloud a backup?

Both are sync services with the same weakness. Deleting a photo or file on one device removes it from the others, and the trash or Recently Deleted folder only keeps it for a limited period. Treat them as convenient access to your files, then back those files up somewhere else.

Does a NAS count as a backup?

A NAS is a good place to hold a backup copy, but a NAS on its own is just storage. It becomes a backup when it keeps snapshots or versions, and it counts toward 3-2-1 when it is also replicated to an offsite location such as a cloud backup service.

How often should I test my backup?

Restore a few files at least twice a year, and restore a whole folder to a different location once a year. For a business, test after any change to the backup system, a server or your Microsoft 365 setup. A restore is the only real proof the backup works.

What is the cheapest way to back up a home computer?

An external USB drive running Windows File History or macOS Time Machine covers hardware failure and accidental deletion for the cost of the drive. Add a cloud backup of your photos and documents so a fire or theft doesn't take both copies.

Keep reading

More on backup & data

Tell us what's going on. We'll tell you what it costs.

Free consultations for businesses. Fixed-price quotes before any work starts.

Private design preview